This ‘Dogg’ won’t stop: Why Nathan MacKinnon is even more dominant than you think
Thirteen seasons into his NHL career, Nathan MacKinnon has been called many things.
Intense. No-nonsense. Relentless. Unstoppable. Process-driven. Inevitable.
But best player in the NHL? That’s Connor McDavid. Best point scorer? That’s McDavid or Nikita Kucherov, depending on who you ask. Best sniper? That’s been Alex Ovechkin or Auston Matthews throughout MacKinnon’s career. Fastest player? McDavid again. MacKinnon isn’t even the best player from Cole Harbour, N.S., a Maritime town of 25,000. His boyhood idol and pal Sidney Crosby carries that title.
With all eyes on the powerhouse Colorado Avalanche‘s postseason chase, MacKinnon isn’t interested in what he’s not. Right now, he’s the best player on the best team in the NHL — a second Stanley Cup ring is within his grasp. Next up: the Vegas Golden Knights in the Western Conference Final.
So, what is MacKinnon, exactly? Well, he’s way better than you think…
💥 Present
“I want to enjoy myself, but I’m not here to enjoy myself.“
— Milano Cortina Olympic Games, February 2026
Rumors of Nathan MacKinnon’s single-minded pursuit of success have spread through hockey circles for years. His extreme diet. The legendary workouts. The high standard he holds teammates to in practice. His deflection of personal milestones. More recently, his swimming pool routine.
Both the true stories and tall tales paint the sketch of a determined, obsessed superstar hellbent on winning.
But mock MacKinnon’s habits at your own peril. For all the criticism of highly-paid athletes in questionable fitness or giving their teams hit-or-miss effort, MacKinnon’s philosophy is simple: maximize your chances. A hockey career or competitive team window can disappear in the blink of an eye. MacKinnon isn’t interested in having regrets when it’s all said and done.
And the hard work is paying off.
In the 21 seasons of the salary cap era, MacKinnon is in exclusive company for MVP consideration. Here are the five players to earn top-five Hart Trophy finishes more than three times.
| Player | Hart Trophy Wins | Top-Five Finishes |
| Connor McDavid | 3 | 9 |
| Sidney Crosby | 2 | 9 |
| Nathan MacKinnon | 1 | 7 |
| Alex Ovechkin | 3 | 5 |
| Nikita Kucherov | 1 | 4 |
‘Nate Dogg’ is looking up only at Crosby and McDavid, the generational pillars of the last two decades. The rest of the era’s superstars don’t approach how consistently exceptional MacKinnon has been. You need to combine the top-five MVP finishes of Patrick Kane, Anze Kopitar, Corey Perry, Daniel Sedin, Henrik Sedin, Steven Stamkos, and Jonathan Toews (one each) to tie MacKinnon’s seven such seasons.
Whether MacKinnon, McDavid, or Kucherov takes home the Hart Trophy for 2025-26, the breadth of his consideration is already historically significant.
MacKinnon also has a couple of Wayne Gretzky-esque feats on his résumé: 97 even-strength points this past season, the most since Gretzky (1990-91); and points in 35 consecutive home games to start a season in 2023-24, five games shy of Gretzky’s record (1988-89). For context, MacKinnon was only born in 1995.
By HockeyStats.com‘s Wins Above Replacement over the last three seasons, MacKinnon has no equals.
The Halifax-born center has provided nearly five wins of value more than any other NHL player since 2023-24. While MacKinnon’s been extremely durable — missing just five games in three seasons — he’s also the league leader in WAR on a per-game basis.
Despite the MVP support and league-wide respect, MacKinnon isn’t thought of in the same breath as the top 15 or 20 forwards in NHL history. But at just 30 years old, these are the ghosts he’s already hunting down.
⏳ Past
“It’s pretty shocking. Felt like we were in total control… Yeah, I don’t know. I’m in shock, to be honest… We still couldn’t beat them. Yeah, I don’t know. I don’t know what we’re gonna do.”
— Round One, Game 7 loss to Dallas, May 2025
After lifting the Stanley Cup at 26, MacKinnon, along with Cale Makar, Mikko Rantanen, Gabriel Landeskog, and coach Jared Bednar surely thought they were prime candidates to make regular deep playoff runs in the years to follow. Young, talented, and resilient, the core was built to be a mini-dynasty.
Not so fast.
The next three postseasons produced a single series victory:
- humbled in an opening round loss to the Seattle Kraken in seven games in 2023;
- Round 2 exit in six games to the Dallas Stars in 2024;
- 2-0 collapse in Game Seven to Dallas, only this time in Round One and courtesy of a third-period hat trick from Rantanen, now playing on a division rival.
With two of these series decided in seven games, it ran the Avalanche’s Game 7 losing streak to seven, including 0-5 in the MacKinnon era. Their franchise player has just two points in the five losses. But it’s more puck luck than existential crisis — MacKinnon has one goal on 26 shots in Game 7. That dam should burst eventually. In 26 potential series-clinching games for either team overall, MacKinnon has 36 points and the Avs are 15-11. But the Game 7 yips remain an active part of Colorado lore.
If you zoom out from a few memorable losses, MacKinnon’s postseason dominance is clear. 104 games into his playoff career, he has the fifth most points per game in NHL history (minimum 100 games).
Despite playing in a modest era for offense, MacKinnon puts up four points for every three postseason games. It’s a tick behind contemporaries McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. In the grand scheme of NHL postseason play, few have delivered like MacKinnon in the spring. In 18 career series, he’s posted at least one point per game 16 times.
It’s unlikely MacKinnon will ever play on an NHL team as good as this one.
The Presidents’ Trophy-winning Avalanche led the league in both goals for and fewest goals against. They’ve barely broken a playoff sweat, dispatching the overmatched Los Angeles Kings and dangerous Minnesota Wild in nine games. But there is only one goal in Denver right now: lifting the Stanley Cup. A well-fought battle or a productive series from MacKinnon is irrelevant. Just ask McDavid and his Edmonton Oilers‘ teammates what second-place feels like this time of year.
🔮 Future
“Obviously I’m 30, but I just feel like I’m kind of getting started, to be honest. I think your hockey prime is a lot longer these days.”
— After a scorching start, December 2025
We’ve established MacKinnon has been the league’s most valuable player over the last three seasons. If not reputationally, his statistical case is strong. And while his career postseason scoring rate may dip in his 30s, MacKinnon is also one of the best playoff performers in the NHL’s long history.
Parking the next month’s pivotal impact on MacKinnon’s legacy, what could his future look like?
By starting young and reaching all-world status by 22, MacKinnon is trending to become one of the greatest scorers ever by both volume and efficiency. Era adjusted stats — which normalize league-wide scoring environment, schedule length, and roster size — put each player’s output on a neutral scale.
Here’s how MacKinnon’s adjusted point totals look through his age-30 season:
Gretzky. Jagr. McDavid. Crosby… MacKinnon.
Through a combination of exceptional production, good health and entering the NHL at 18, MacKinnon is fifth in era-adjusted points through his age-30 season. Very few people consider him among this caliber of player. But the numbers don’t lie: MacKinnon is on a short list of mid-career G.O.A.Ts.
The scariest part? All that dedication to fitness has him playing arguably his best hockey at 30:
- He’s scored at a 118-point pace over the last nine seasons.
- He’s scored at a 130-point pace over the last four seasons.
- He just set a career high in goals (53) and won his first Rocket Richard Trophy.
- He had the fourth-best plus-minus (+57) of any forward since 1986-87.
- He averaged 22:16 of ice time last season.
- He’s scored in six consecutive playoff games entering the Conference Finals.
After 13 seasons, this isn’t a guy cashing checks and easing into the back nine of his career. It’s one of the fittest, most committed athletes in sports dominating and wanting more. MacKinnon is already the only player to win a Hart, Lindsay, Calder, Richard, Byng, and Stanley Cup. Internationally, he’s also won a IIHF World Hockey Championship, 4 Nations Face-off title and MVP and Olympic silver.
How would a second Stanley Cup and Hart Trophy look? Or a Conn Smythe Trophy?
The Dogg is the type of ‘dawg’ that could play into his 40s, cut from the Crosby, Jagr, Zdeno Chara cloth of loving the game and dedicating himself physically to enduring more than two decades.
In March, I projected MacKinnon’s final career stat line: 686 goals, 1,195 assists, 1,881 points.
Those totals would rank 12th, third, and fourth all-time as of today. While the exercise is illustrative, it shows a reasonable expectation of the level MacKinnon can reach with good health.
A closer look at MacKinnon’s career reveals so much more than a fiery superstar. He’s not quite a prodigious talent like McDavid. Or a visceral, sniping savant like Ovechkin. Or a distinguished hockey sage like Crosby. MacKinnon is parts of all of them, obsessively hardwired over time into a relentless, lethal package. And when it’s all said and done, he might end up among them as one of the best forwards to ever live.
_____
Recently by Paul Pidutti
- What can the modern history of No. 1 picks tell us about Toronto’s future?
- Father Time is the destroyer of playoff dreams
- The five trends that defined the 2025-26 NHL season
_____
CHECK OUT OFF THE ROSTER – NEW EPISODES EVERY WEEKDAY
Off The Roster is Toronto sports. Hosted by Cabbie Richards, Lindsay Dunn, and Dan Riccio, this is the go-to morning conversation for everything happening in the 6ix – Hockey, Baseball, Basketball and everything in between. From breakout performances and questionable trades to throwback jerseys, viral moments, and the stories fans are actually talking about – it’s smart, sharp, and never scripted. Live weekday mornings on the Nation Network YouTube channel and available wherever you stream podcasts, the show delivers real opinions, real chemistry, and real Toronto energy. Missed an episode? Catch up anytime. Off The Roster—The new sound of the 6ix.